regarding
plea negotiations in federal courts around our nation.
Contrary to the assumption of the Supreme Court and other observers that
plea negotiation ordinarily occurs in an atmosphere of informed choice, private defense attorneys, public defenders, and appointed attorneys are all subject to bureaucratic pressures and conflicts of interest that seem unavoidable in any regime grounded on the guilty plea.
It was not until fourteen years after Brady that a court first analyzed the applicability of a prosecutor's disclosure duty in a pre-plea context, finding that intentional prosecutorial suppression during
plea negotiations could deprive a defendant of his or her due process rights.
Kentucky underscores the defense bar's stake in participating in the ABA standard-setting process to guide the development of defense counsel's obligations in
plea negotiations.
3d DCA May 8, 2002), the trial judge initiated
plea negotiations with the defendant after his first trial had ended in a hung jury, strongly suggesting that he accept the state's four-year offer.
Frye (15)--the Court concluded that the right to effective assistance of counsel applies to
plea negotiations, clarified how defendants can obtain relief when their attorneys have failed them in the plea process, explained what relief is available, and expanded the requirements of effective lawyering at that crucial stage in the criminal process.
48) Following this decision, the Supreme Court granted the State's petition for certiorari to resolve the proper application of Strickland to
plea negotiation and defendant's decision making.
It is our view that judicial participation in
plea negotiations can
83) This present shortage of certified and qualified court interpreters harms non-English-speaking defendants who choose to plead guilty because these defendants may have unskilled court interpreters performing interpretation during
plea negotiations.
Its integrity will continue to exert unseen pressures on the
plea negotiation process.
The Second Circuit then found that even without this conclusion, evidence of an immunity negotiation has more probative value than evidence of a
plea negotiation.
deficient counsel during the
plea negotiation process.
81) The disparate bargaining powers between the parties to the
plea negotiation raise the fear that the errors mentioned in the previous paragraph will systematically work to the detriment of the defendant.
68) Mezzanatto appealed his conviction, arguing that he could not waive the Rules' exclusion of his
plea negotiation statements, even for the limited purpose of impeachment.
Specifically, I note that your records of this matter do not reflect that when you telephoned me you indicated it seemed difficult to believe that
plea negotiation letters could be releasable prior to trial.