Ryan also brings in Sayce's philological work again: in his The Principles of Comparative Philology
(1874) Sayce also explored the Turanian language group in relation to languages that included Finnish, Lapp, and Mordvinian, and suggested Turanian was one of the earliest forms of a primitive European language and a counterpart of the Indo-European languages.
More obedient, but still receptive and curious, L'Eleve reacts to the lecture about Comparative Philology
with various degrees of enthusiasm.
The identification of language as a privileged site of history is one of the most powerful and enduring legacies of nineteenth-century comparative philology
, whose major successes include comparative grammar, the reclassification of languages into families, and the reconstruction of the lost protolanguages from which families of extant languages descended.
A rereading of the classics of comparative philology
, or at least Fox's (1995) recent summary of the methods of reconstruction, should have warned the authors.
The family with whom he lodged in New York City noted his obsessive study of comparative philology
more than once.
Rousseau's Essay on the Origin of Languages exemplified the Romantic philology that would evolve into comparative philology
; in turn, comparative philology
advanced a linguistic principle fundamental to Derrida's deconstruction of Rousseau's linguistic theory.
Given the occasional displacement of comparative philology
in favour of semantic evidence for lexemes in recent lexicographical exercises, the strong philological emphasis of Koehler-Baumgartner will ensure the continuing usefulness and importance of both the original and this English edition for serious students of Hebrew.
In the comparative philology
of Bopp and Humboldt and, a century later, Propp's Morphology of the Folktale (1928), the methods of comparative analysis honed in empirical fields were transposed to the realms of grammar and shaped cultural phenomena, and a nonnatural basis for comparison came to the fore.
The commissions would be composed of nonpartisan experts, appointed by the governor; Charles McCarthy, in The Wisconsin Idea (1912), wrote that "to elect a railroad commission would be as ridiculous as electing a professor of comparative philology
at the University" (p.
The development of comparative philology
in the 19th century, together with ethnological discoveries in the 20th, established the main contours of mythology, the science of myth.
Winning's Manual of Comparative Philology
For the benefit of readers who may not be familiar with the orthodox brand of comparative philology
that Mozeson is seeking to discredit, some background is in order.
These few preliminary pages offer a kind of "to do list" for Tolkien scholars and will hopefully spur further investigation of: Tolkien's literary antecedents, particularly the Victorian and Edwardian; the significance of the parallel efforts at comparative philology
and comparative mythology undertaken in Tolkien's milieu; the interplay of topoi in the works of Tolkien, Lewis, Williams, Barfield, and their friends--which Shippey calls the "Inkling conversation"; Tolkien's early poetry in all its varied forms and revisions; and more besides.
Born in Arbroath and raised in Cornwall, Dr Russell read Literae Humaniores at Jesus College, Oxford, before studying for his MPhil in General Linguistics and Comparative Philology
, also at Jesus College.
Salisbury Professor of Sanskrit and Comparative Philology